| Keeper | Date Appointed | Date Vacated | Salary | Remarks |
| James P. Keating | Dec. 28, 1854 | Feb. 1, 1859 | $1,000 | Removed |
| W.C. Wiley | Feb. 1, 1859 | $1,000 | Salary reduced to $800 on Sept. 1, 1859 | |
| J.N. Covarrubias | Oct. 9, 1859 | Mar. 13, 1860 | $800 | Resigned |
| Joseph Reiner | Mar. 13, 1860 | Nov. 16, 1860 | $800 | Resigned |
| James P. Keating | Nov. 16, 1860 | $800 | Resigned | |
| W.C. Price | Feb. 16, 1861 | Nov. 23, 1867 | $1,000 | |
| J.D. Jenkins | Nov. 23, 1867 | Apr. 24, 1871 | $1,000 | Removed |
| Isaac Swain | Apr. 24, 1871 | May 20, 1871 | $1,000 | Declined |
| Enos A. Wall | May 20, 1871 | |||
| James J. Ferree | Mar. 5, 1872 | June 27, 1873 | $1,000 | Resigned |
| Robert D. Israel | June 27, 1873 | Mar. 23, 1891 | $1,000 | Salary reduced to $800 on Jan. 1, 1880. Transferred to new Point Loma Light after old light ceased operation. |
CNM VIP Voice 